A 3-step guide for Brooklyn owners

How to Find Experienced Roofing Professionals in Brooklyn: A 3-Step Guide

Where to find roofers who actually know Brooklyn buildings, how to confirm their experience is real, and how to compare them before anyone sets up a ladder.

By the All State Roofing – Brooklyn teamUpdated October 202610 min read
Quick answer: find experienced roofers through people with the same kind of building as yours, not door-knockers or generic ads. Then verify: a DCWP Home Improvement Contractor license, proof of insurance, a long local track record, photos and references from jobs like yours, and hands-on experience with your roof system and NYC’s rules. Finally, have two or three of them inspect the roof and compare how they diagnose it, not just what they charge.

“Experienced” is the word every roofing ad uses. What you actually want is a roofer who has done your kind of roof, on your kind of building, in this city, many times. A crew that’s great at shingle roofs in the suburbs can struggle with a flat roof behind a brownstone parapet. Here’s how we’d find the right people if we were in your shoes.

Step 1: Build a Short List From the Right Sources

Where you find a roofer says a lot about what you’ll get.

Good places to start

  • Neighbors with the same building type. On a block of brownstones in Park Slope or limestones in Crown Heights, someone has had their roof done recently. Ask who, and whether it’s still dry.
  • Your building’s super, managing agent or co-op board. They deal with roofers constantly and know who shows up and who doesn’t.
  • Reviews that describe real jobs. Look for reviews that name the building and the problem, and ones written long after the work was done.
  • The DCWP license lookup. Any roofer on your list should show up at nyc.gov/dcwp under “Check License.”

Places to be careful

  • Door-knockers after a storm, especially with “leftover materials.”
  • Flyers with only a cell number and no business name or license.
  • Lead sites that sell your request to whoever pays, so you don’t know who’s coming.

Step 2: Verify Their Experience and Credentials

Years in business matter, but only alongside proof. These are the things that separate real experience from a good sales pitch.

A license and insurance that match the business

In NYC, home improvement work costing more than $200 on a residential building requires a Home Improvement Contractor license from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. That includes handymen and general contractors who “also do roofs.” Ask for a certificate of insurance too. Our guide on how to tell whether a roofing company is worth hiring covers the license, contract and payment rules in detail.

Experience with your roof system

Roofing systems aren’t interchangeable, and neither are the skills. Ask which of these they install and repair regularly:

Roof systemCommon onAsk them about
EPDM rubberBrownstones, rowhouses, walk-upsSeam work and flashing at parapets and bulkheads
Modified bitumen (torch-down)Rowhouses, two-families, mixed-useFDNY Certificates of Fitness and who serves as fire guard
TPO and PVCMixed-use, commercial, roof decksHeat-welded seams and detailing around equipment
Asphalt shinglesDetached homes in Marine Park, Dyker Heights, MidwoodNailing pattern, underlayment, valleys and ventilation
SlateVictorians in Ditmas Park, mansions in Clinton HillSlate repair experience and Landmarks requirements

Experience with NYC rules

An experienced Brooklyn roofer can tell you, without looking it up, when a job needs a Department of Buildings permit, whether your block is landmarked and needs Landmarks Preservation Commission approval, what FDNY requires for torch work, and why a new roof can’t go over two existing ones. If those questions get blank looks, that’s your answer.

Photos and references from jobs like yours

Ask for photos of similar roofs they’ve done: same building type, same roof system. Better yet, ask for a reference on a job that’s a few years old. Anyone can make a new roof look good on day one.

Close-up of a roofer's cordless drill driving a fastener
Experience shows in the details: fasteners, flashing and how the roof is tied into the walls.

Step 3: Interview and Compare Two or Three Roofers

Have each shortlisted roofer inspect the roof. Watch how they work, then compare what they tell you.

What experienced roofers do on the first visit

  • Ask where and when it leaks before they go up.
  • Inspect the whole roof, including parapets, coping, drains and flashing.
  • Check the stain inside and trace it back to the roof.
  • Count the roof layers and check for soft, wet areas.
  • Show you photos and explain the cause in plain English.
  • Give you options, including “repair it, it’s not time for a new roof” when that’s true.

Questions that reveal real experience

  1. How many roofs like mine have you done in Brooklyn in the last year?
  2. Where exactly do you think the water is getting in, and how did you rule out other spots?
  3. How will you tie the new roof into the parapet and party wall?
  4. What will you do with the drains: clean, reflash or replace?
  5. What happens if you find rotted decking, and what does it cost per board or sheet?
  6. Does this need a permit or Landmarks approval, and who files it?
  7. Who will be on my roof, and how long have they been with you?
  8. Can I talk to someone whose roof you did a few years ago?

How to compare the answers

Line up the written estimates item by item. The roofer with the most specific diagnosis is usually the one with the most experience, even when they’re not the cheapest. Wildly different prices usually mean different jobs: one coating, one overlay, one tear-off. Make sure you’re comparing the same scope.

Want an experienced Brooklyn roofer on your short list?

All State Roofing – Brooklyn has worked on the borough’s brownstones, rowhouses, detached homes and commercial roofs since 1997.

Schedule an Inspection

Experienced vs Inexperienced: How to Tell on Your Roof

Experienced roofer

  • Diagnoses before pricing
  • Talks about flashing, drains and parapets, not just the surface
  • Knows which permits and rules apply
  • Writes a detailed, line-item scope
  • Has references from similar Brooklyn buildings

Inexperienced roofer

  • Quotes from the street or over the phone
  • Offers a coating or new layer for every problem
  • Unsure about permits or Landmarks
  • One-line estimate with a single total
  • No photos or references to show

What Kind of Experience Your Building Needs

Brownstones and townhouses

Flat roofs behind parapets, cornices, skylights and bulkheads, often on landmarked blocks in Brooklyn Heights, Fort Greene or Bed-Stuy. Look for parapet, coping and cornice experience and familiarity with LPC approvals.

Rowhouses and two-family homes

Shared parapets and party walls in Sunset Park, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst and East Flatbush. Ask how they handle flashing at the party wall and work next to a neighbor’s roof.

Detached homes with shingle roofs

Pitched roofs in Marine Park, Mill Basin, Dyker Heights and Midwood, with coastal wind near Jamaica Bay. Look for proper underlayment, edge and nailing details.

Walk-ups, co-ops and mixed-use buildings

Bigger roofs, tenants below and boards to answer to in Williamsburg, Bushwick and along commercial corridors. Look for written scopes, insurance certificates and experience scheduling around residents and businesses.

Ridge of a dark metal roof against a cloudy sky
Every roof system and building type has its own details. Ask for experience with yours.

Roofer, General Contractor or Handyman?

For a roof that leaks or needs replacing, hire a roofing contractor who does roofs every day. A general contractor may subcontract the roof anyway, and you’ll want to know who’s actually doing it. A handyman can be fine for clearing a gutter, but in NYC anyone doing home improvement work over $200 on a residential building still needs a DCWP license, and roof leaks on attached buildings are rarely a handyman job.

Does it matter how long a roofing company has been around?

It helps. A company that’s been working in Brooklyn for years has seen how its roofs hold up through winters and storms, and it’s likely to still be around if you need it again. Pair that with recent, specific reviews and you have a good picture. You can read what our customers say in their own words.

About this guide

Written by the roofing team at All State Roofing – Brooklyn, a Brooklyn roofing company since 1997. Licensing information is based on NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection guidance.

FAQ

Finding an Experienced Roofer in Brooklyn: FAQs

How do I find an experienced roofer in Brooklyn?

Start with neighbors who have the same kind of building, your super or managing agent, and reviews that describe real jobs. Then confirm the roofer’s DCWP license and insurance, ask for photos and references from similar roofs, and have two or three inspect the roof.

What questions should I ask a roofer about experience?

Ask how many roofs like yours they’ve done in Brooklyn recently, where they think the water enters and why, how they’ll tie the roof into parapets and party walls, what happens if they find rotted decking, and whether you can talk to a customer from a few years ago.

Does a handyman need a license to work on my roof in NYC?

Yes, if the home improvement work costs more than $200 on a residential building. NYC requires a DCWP Home Improvement Contractor license for that work, whoever does it.

Should I hire a roofer or a general contractor for a roof leak?

A roofing contractor who works on roofs every day is usually the better choice for leaks and replacements. If you hire a general contractor, ask who will actually do the roof.

Why does roof system experience matter?

EPDM, torch-down, TPO, PVC, shingles and slate each use different materials and methods. A roofer skilled with one isn’t automatically skilled with another, so ask about experience with your specific roof.

How many roofers should I get quotes from?

Two or three, after each has inspected the roof. Compare their diagnosis and line-item scope, not just the total price.

What does an experienced roofer look at first?

Where and when it leaks, then the whole roof: surface, seams, flashing, parapets, coping, drains, skylights and the number of layers, plus the stain inside.

How long has All State Roofing – Brooklyn been in business?

We’ve worked on Brooklyn roofs since 1997, on brownstones, rowhouses, detached homes, co-ops and commercial buildings.

Put an Experienced Brooklyn Roofer on Your Short List

All State Roofing – Brooklyn has roofed the borough’s homes and buildings since 1997. Call for an inspection, photos and a written, line-item quote.

All State Roofing – Brooklyn

235 43rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11232

(929) 695-6095

Emergency roof calls taken

Tap to Call a Roofer