How to Tell Whether a Roofing Company Is Worth Hiring in Brooklyn
Ten checks that separate a real NYC roofing contractor from a crew that disappears with your deposit, including the license, contract and payment rules New York City actually enforces.
We’ve been roofing in Brooklyn since 1997, and a lot of our calls start the same way: “Another roofer patched it twice and it’s still leaking,” or “I have three quotes and they’re all over the place.” Most of those headaches could have been avoided with the checks below. They work whether you hire us or anyone else.
1. Check the NYC Home Improvement Contractor License First
In New York City, a contractor doing home improvement work that costs more than $200 on a residential building needs a Home Improvement Contractor license from DCWP. Roof repairs and replacements on houses, brownstones and other residential buildings fall under that rule. New construction, plumbing and purely electrical work are handled differently.
How to check a roofer’s license
- Ask for the DCWP license number and the exact business name on the license.
- Look it up at nyc.gov/dcwp under “Check License,” or call 311.
- Make sure the name on the license matches the name on the estimate, the contract and the truck.
Why the license matters more than you’d think
DCWP runs a Trust Fund that can repay homeowners when a licensed contractor doesn’t finish the job or owes them money. If you hire an unlicensed contractor, you’re not eligible. In September 2024, DCWP said it had returned more than $1.2 million to consumers through the Trust Fund in the previous year and launched a public “Wall of Shame” of contractors cited for working without a license, a roofing company among them. More than 13,000 home improvement contractors hold a DCWP license, so there’s no reason to take a chance on one that doesn’t.
Hiring for a co-op, condo or commercial building?
Boards and managing agents usually have their own requirements on top of licensing, such as specific insurance limits and certificates naming the building. Ask for those in writing before the job is scheduled.
2. Ask for Proof of Insurance, in Writing
Roofing is dangerous work, and an injury or damage on your property shouldn’t become your problem. Ask for a certificate of insurance showing general liability coverage, and confirm the contractor carries workers’ compensation, which New York requires employers to have for their workers.
- Ask for the certificate to be sent to you directly from the insurance agent, not just a photo of an old one.
- Check that the policy dates cover your job.
- For attached buildings, ask whether neighbors’ roofs and property are covered if they need to be accessed.
3. Run a Business Background Check
Call 311 and ask for a “Business Background Check” to see a contractor’s complaint history with the city. If the company also works on Long Island or in Westchester, check with the agencies there and with the New York State Department of State. Then search the company name with “complaint” and read what comes up.
4. Watch How They Inspect Your Roof
You can learn more about a roofer in the first fifteen minutes on your roof than from any ad. A roofer worth hiring:
- Asks where the water shows up inside and when: every rain, only in heavy rain, after snow.
- Gets on the roof and checks the whole thing, not just the spot above the stain.
- Looks at parapets, coping, flashing, drains, skylights and the bulkhead on a flat roof, or valleys, chimney flashing and vents on a shingle roof.
- Takes photos and shows you what they found.
- Explains the cause in plain English and tells you whether a repair will hold or the roof is past it.
What if a roofer quotes over the phone?
A ballpark is fine. A firm price without seeing the roof is not. On Brooklyn’s attached buildings, water often travels several feet along boards and party walls before it shows up inside, so a roofer who doesn’t look is guessing, and you’ll pay for the guess.
5. Get More Than One Written Estimate
Get written estimates from more than one licensed contractor. Under NYC rules, a contractor must give you a written estimate if you ask for one. They can charge a reasonable fee for it, but they have to tell you the cost first.
What a good roofing estimate includes
| The estimate should say | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| The exact problem and where it is | Shows they actually found the cause |
| Tear-off or layover, and how many layers come off | Codes don’t allow a new roof over two or more existing layers |
| The roofing system and material | EPDM, TPO, PVC, modified bitumen, shingles: they aren’t interchangeable |
| Flashing, coping, drains and skylights | Where most Brooklyn leaks start; often left out of cheap quotes |
| A price per board or sheet for rotted decking | Stops surprise charges once the old roof is off |
| Permits, cleanup and debris removal | Avoids hidden extras at the end |
Why are roofing quotes in Brooklyn so different?
Because they’re often quoting different jobs. One roofer prices a coating, another an overlay, a third a full tear-off with new flashing. Line the quotes up item by item. The cheapest quote is often the one that leaves the most out.
6. Read the Contract Before You Sign Anything
NYC sets clear rules for home improvement contracts. Your roofing contract should be:
- In writing and signed by you and the contractor, with a signed copy given to you before work starts.
- In plain English, or in the language you negotiated in.
- Complete: start and completion dates, the work, the materials, the payment schedule, all charges and any guarantees.
- Accompanied by a separate Notice of Cancellation form.
The permit notice most homeowners never get
Before you sign, the contractor has to tell you in writing which permits the job needs, who will get them, the steps involved, the estimated permit fees and how you can check the permit status. For roofing in Brooklyn, that can include a Department of Buildings permit for a full replacement and Landmarks Preservation Commission approval on landmarked blocks. If a roofer shrugs off permits, keep looking.
Want a quote you can actually compare?
All State Roofing – Brooklyn gives written, line-item quotes after an on-roof inspection, with photos of what we find.
7. Never Pay Cash, and Never More Than 25% Upfront
NYC’s consumer agency tells homeowners never to pay in cash or without a contract, and to pay no more than 25% of the total contract amount upfront. Keep records of every payment and every piece of paperwork. Contractors also aren’t allowed to arrange or offer home improvement loans, so if you’re financing a new roof, do it through your own bank or credit union.
8. Test Their Brooklyn Knowledge
A general contractor who “also does roofs” may not know Brooklyn’s buildings or rules. Ask a few questions and listen to the answers.
Questions to ask a Brooklyn roofing contractor
- Where do you think the water is getting in, and why not somewhere else?
- Will you check the parapets, coping and party-wall flashing, not just the roof surface?
- Is this a tear-off or a layover? How many layers are on there now?
- Does this job need a DOB permit? Is my block landmarked?
- If you’re using torch-down, does your crew hold FDNY Certificates of Fitness, and who’s the fire guard?
- What happens if you find rotted decking, and what does each board or sheet cost?
- Do you need access to my neighbor’s roof, and how will you handle it?
- Who will actually be on my roof, and who do I call if something goes wrong?
Clear, specific answers are a good sign. “Don’t worry about it” is not.
9. Read Reviews the Right Way
Star ratings are a starting point. The useful part is what the reviews say. Look for reviews that name the building, the problem and what was done: a 1930s house with too many layers, a warehouse roof, shingles blowing onto the sidewalk. Reviews written a year or more after the job tell you how the work held up. A wall of short, vague five-star reviews posted in the same week tells you very little. You can read our customer reviews, copied word for word from Yelp.
10. Know the Red Flags
Red flags
- Door-knocking after a storm, or “leftover materials from a job down the block”
- Cash only, or a large deposit before any work
- No license number, or a name that doesn’t match the license
- A price today that “expires tonight”
- Silver paint or a coating offered as the fix for every leak
- No mention of permits, flashing or what’s under the roof
Green flags
- Licensed, insured and happy to prove it
- Inspects the whole roof and shows you photos
- Written, line-item estimate and a compliant contract
- Tells you when a repair is enough
- Knows Brooklyn buildings, permits and Landmarks rules
- A real local track record you can check
What to Do If a Roofer Already Let You Down
If you hired a contractor who didn’t finish, did poor work or won’t return calls, you still have options.
- Document everything: the contract, payments, texts and dated photos of the roof and any leaks.
- File a complaint: call 311 or go to nyc.gov/dcwp to report contract or quality-of-work disputes.
- Ask about the Trust Fund: if the contractor was DCWP-licensed, you may be eligible for repayment.
- Get the roof looked at: an independent inspection with photos shows what was done and what still needs fixing.
Why Hiring the Right Roofer Matters More in Brooklyn
Close to half of Brooklyn’s homes were built before 1939, and most are attached. A bad roof job on a rowhouse in Bed-Stuy or a brownstone in Park Slope doesn’t just leak into your top floor; it can leak into your neighbor’s. Flat roofs behind parapets, landmarked blocks in Brooklyn Heights and Clinton Hill, shingle roofs facing the wind off Jamaica Bay in Mill Basin and Bergen Beach: each needs a roofer who has seen it before. Choosing well the first time is cheaper than paying twice.
Hiring a Roofing Company in Brooklyn: FAQs
Does a roofer need a license in NYC?
Yes, for most home jobs. NYC requires a Department of Consumer and Worker Protection Home Improvement Contractor license for home improvement work costing more than $200 on a residential building, which includes roof repairs and replacements on homes.
How do I check a roofing contractor’s license in NYC?
Ask for the DCWP license number, then look it up at nyc.gov/dcwp under Check License or call 311. Make sure the business name on the license matches the estimate and contract.
How much should I pay a roofer upfront?
NYC’s consumer agency advises paying no more than 25% of the total contract amount upfront, never paying in cash and never paying without a signed contract.
What should a roofing contract include in NYC?
It should be written and signed, in plain English or the language you negotiated in, list dates, the work, materials, payment schedule, all charges and any guarantees, and come with a separate Notice of Cancellation form. You should get a signed copy before work starts.
Do roofers have to tell me about permits?
Yes. Before you sign, a NYC home improvement contractor must tell you in writing which permits are needed, who will get them, the steps, estimated fees and how to check permit status.
How many roofing quotes should I get?
At least two or three from licensed contractors, after each has inspected the roof. Compare them line by line: tear-off or layover, materials, flashing, decking prices, permits and cleanup.
Is the cheapest roofing quote a bad sign?
Not always, but it often leaves things out, like flashing, decking or permits, or prices a coating instead of a real repair. Ask what’s included before deciding.
What can I do if a roofer did a bad job?
Document everything, file a complaint through 311 or nyc.gov/dcwp, and if the contractor was DCWP-licensed, ask whether you’re eligible for the Home Improvement Trust Fund. An independent roof inspection with photos helps too.
Is All State Roofing – Brooklyn connected to Allstate Insurance?
No. All State Roofing – Brooklyn is an independent Brooklyn roofing contractor and is not affiliated with Allstate Insurance.
Looking for a Roofer Who Passes Every Check?
All State Roofing – Brooklyn has worked on the borough’s roofs since 1997. License and insurance proof on request, an inspection with photos and a written, line-item quote before any work starts.
All State Roofing – Brooklyn
235 43rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Emergency roof calls taken